Why Leaning on One Person Is Organisational Self-Sabotage
“Oh, good old Doris will do it.”
Every small charity has a Doris. She does the jobs, answers the calls and knows where everything is kept. Everyone relies on her. Most charities are a lot closer to losing her than they realise.
The Indispensable Trustee
I was directly involved with one small charity that leant on one trustee so hard that the work was all they thought about, day in, day out. Because they’d been leant on that much, they came to feel indispensable. They stopped listening to other people and stopped consulting them. They stopped spreading the jobs about and took on the entire burden.
Meanwhile the rest of the board stopped doing anything at all. What was the point in asking anyone else when Doris would do it? The charity started failing, and didn’t notice, because it had handed everything to one person.
On a different board, the hero simply burnt out and went AWOL. No calls answered, no meetings attended. When the hero goes, everything goes. You’re rebuilding from scratch and scratting around for people to do jobs everyone had taken for granted would just get done.
The Quality Drop
Overwork doesn’t only cause resignations. It causes mistakes.
Going back about twenty years, I saw an overworked treasurer, doing every single job, produce a separate set of annual accounts for each bank account. That was the easiest way for them to do it. Reserves sat in one account, restricted funds in another, day-to-day money in a third, and nobody had a consolidated picture.
The charity thought it was doing really well. In fact 90% of its money was restricted, and it couldn’t pay some of its bills. It was a complete mess to sort out. And I can’t blame the treasurer. They did what was easiest because of the position they’d been put in.
How I Spot It as a Chair
The first thing I notice is that people stop being as engaged. Then they start turning up late, or working late constantly and never switching off. You see a lot of sickness absence, or people working regardless of what’s going on in their lives.
Feedback gets more negative. People get snappy and snipey, because they’re being asked for more than they can give. And the quality errors creep in, all the time.
I Was the Hero
God, yes. It cost me a lot. I got to a point where I couldn’t escape the organisation. It was taking over my life. The kiddos were young, I was sorting them out and doing charity work at the same time, and I was missing out.
So I stepped back and resigned as a trustee. Three months later I went back on, because they couldn’t cope without me. But this time I put boundaries in place, and the charity accepted I’d been carrying far too many roles.
Now I’m comfortable saying no. I redirect: have you thought about this person? Is that one for the next meeting, or for the volunteer coordinator? When I do say yes, I give a date. If they need it sooner, I suggest they find somebody else. No is a powerful and underused word, and I learned that the hard way.
The Boundaries That Actually Stick
The best practice I’ve seen, across several charities I work with, starts on day one. Ask every new volunteer how many hours they can commit, and check in regularly that it still holds. If somebody says two hours a month, they get two hours a month.
Spread the asks across a wide pool, not just the person who always says yes. One charity won’t ask the same person more than three times in a row. The fourth time, they go to somebody else.
Run a skills audit and log it. Then, when there’s a social media job, you know which volunteers are good at it and enjoy it, and you ask them. And if one person says yes to everything, question why.
The Art of NOT Being Stupid
Agree hours up front and stick to them. Rotate the asks. Match tasks to logged skills. Get what lives in the hero’s head written down The ‘My Head Only’ Manual covers how. Put workload on the board agenda before somebody walks, not after. If you’re a trustee who recognises yourself in this, The Burnout Warning Signs: Protecting Trustees is worth ten minutes.
Final Thought
Next time something needs doing, notice whose name comes into your head first. Then ask someone else.


